Back to: Small studies
|
A small study on cosmic radiation
The role of cosmic radiation in climate change has been discussed in various publications.
On this internet site I put a small article with some comments on it. Recently I found some interesting data on the internet (see data sources at the bottom) on the amount of cosmic radiation in time. This enables one to see whether a correlation between solar activity / cosmic radiation and the temperature on Earth could be found.
![]() figure1: Level of cosmic radiation vs. global temperature anomaly [°C] In figure 1 the level of cosmic radiation is plotted against the global temperature anomaly (GISS, monthly data). No significant correlation can be observed (r² = 0.0536). Only a very slight negative trend can be discerned, but this is not statistically significant.
![]() figure2: Level of cosmic radiation vs. timeline of global temperature anomaly [°C] Figure 2 shows the timeline. If there would be a (very weak) correllation between cosmic radiation hidden in the "natural noise" of the temperature signal on Earth, a tendency towards slightly tilted (in a "NW-SE" orientation) timelines should be observable. This is not the case. Most scatter is in a much more vertical (or even "SW-NE") direction. Finally one can take a look at the individual signals. In figure 3 the temperature anomaly on Earth (vs. 1951-1980) is plotted against time. This shows a clear trend (r² = 0.547). This is not the case for the amount of cosmic radiation (r² = 0.005). However, the role of the solar activity can be observed. The solar maxima (1958-59, 1969-71, 1990-92, 2000-2003) can be discerned quite well.
![]() figure3: Global temperature anomaly [°C] for 1953-2006
![]() figure4: Level of cosmic radiation for 1953-2006 Conclusion There is hardly an appreciable correlation between the amount of cosmic radiation and the temperature on Earth. At most it can give rise to a minor contribution. Claims that the current temperature rise on Earth can be explained by solar activity / cosmic radiation levels cannot be upheld. Data sources:
The Cosmic ray data come from this directory:
The NASA GISS monthly mean land and sea surface temperature data are here: |